Is he? Santa doesn't come to our house. When I started a family, it didn't feel right to tell my children that Santa Claus was bringing them presents when he wasn't. So I never did. It always seemed to take the focus off of the real reason of the season... celebrating the birth of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. The concept is the same with the Easter Bunny, Tooth Fairy, etc. Why pretend that what is isn't real... is?
I have always felt great about this decision, and my children have appreciated it. Unfortunately, I have run into some cultural speed bumps along the way. Many adults have said things like these to my children:
"What's Santa bringing you for Christmas?"
"If you don't believe in Santa, then he won't bring you any presents!"
"You have to be good or Santa Claus won't come!"
This is extremely confusing to my children, who know that such a scenario is not the case, but wonder why adults, who are supposed to be honest and helpful to children, would tell them so.
A bigger problem, however, is with friends of my children and their parents. When other kids start talking about Santa to them, my kids think it's silly to play along. This has created some real opposition from both children and parents. I have received multiple complaints, even "warnings".
I believe that culturally we are way off base in our current creation of Santa Claus, and other imaginary visitors. Let me explain why:
1) As I've already mentioned, a focus on Santa Claus takes the focus off Christ.
2) I subscribe to the philosophy of "Core Phase" described in A Thomas Jefferson Education by Oliver DeMille. This phase takes place from age 0-8. From the TJED website:
Core Phase is that magical time of nurture and growth, almost like a cocoon. The lessons of Core Phase are taught through work and play as a family. They are:
- right and wrong
- good and bad
- true and false
- relationships
- family values
- family routines and responsibilities
- learning accountability
- the value and love of work
During this Phase children are taught the basics of the family’s faith, and how to arrive at and recognize truth. (Italics added.)
(For more information about Core Phase, see:
Is the Santa charade conducive to the necessary lessons of this age group? I contest that it opposes them.
3) I want my children to be able to trust me. I want to be the kind of parent that my child can say about me, "my mom would never lie to me". As one Facebook user said, "I could be wrong, but it seems to me that telling children blatant lies and playing them up year after year won't give them as much confidence in the other 'unseen' things they are taught once they find out they were lied to."
Traditions of our Fathers
Elder Richard G. Scott of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles said,
“Your Heavenly Father assigned you to be born into a specific lineage from which you received your inheritance of race, culture, and traditions. That lineage can provide a rich heritage and great reasons to rejoice. Yet you have the responsibility to determine if there is any part of that heritage that must be discarded because it works against the Lord’s plan of happiness.
“You may ask how can one determine when a tradition is in conflict with the teachings of the Lord and should be abandoned? That is not easily done. I have found how difficult it is as I work to overcome some of my own incorrect traditions. … Customs and traditions become an inherent part of us. They are not easy to evaluate objectively. Carefully study the scriptures and counsel of the prophets to understand how the Lord wants you to live. Then evaluate each part of your life and make any adjustments needed. Seek help from another you respect who has been able to set aside some deeply held convictions or traditions that are not in harmony with the Lord’s plan. …"
So are you saying that we should abolish Santa Claus? Christmas isn't Christmas without Santa!
Although we don't focus on Santa, the Jolly Old Fellow is not extinct from our Christmas cheer. We recognize him as a fun character. The kids enjoyed sitting on "Santa's" lap at our ward Christmas party and chatting with him. Imagination is great, as long as it is recognized as such!
We DO celebrate Saint Nicholas Day on December 6th. We tell the story of the great Saint and the children each receive a beautiful picture book about the upcoming holiday, Christmas!
(For more ways to celebrate, see: http://www.stnicholascenter.org/pages/how-to-celebrate/)
And of course, there are lots of fun ways to celebrate Christmas. We love reading and performing the Christmas Nativity, and exchanging gifts on Christmas day. As always, the best way to celebrate Christmas is to do something nice for someone else!
Merry Christmas, everyone! (And to all a good night!)
"But I have commanded you to bring up your children in light and truth."
-Doctrine and Covenants 93:40
-Doctrine and Covenants 93:40



















